Éric Zemmour was convicted this Thursday by the Paris Court of Appeal for racist insult, for having qualified in 2018 the first name of the former columnist of the Canal+ group Hapsatou Sy as an
“insult to France”
. In its judgment, the court confirmed the judgment rendered at first instance in January 2023. The criminal court had found the far-right polemicist guilty of
“public insult due to origin, ethnicity, nation, race or religion”
and imposed a fine of 4,000 euros on him. Éric Zemmour was also ordered to pay 3,000 euros in damages and 2,000 euros in legal fees.
On Thursday, the court of appeal also ordered the founder of the Reconquest! to pay an additional 3,000 euros to Hapsatou Sy for procedural costs. The incriminated comments were made in 2018 during the recording of the
“Terriens du Dimanche”
show , broadcast on C8.
“It’s your first name that is an insult to France. France is not a virgin land, it is a land with a history, with a past. Your first name is not in history, you are in the depths of France
,” Eric Zemmour told Hapsatou Sy.
“3 to 4000 hate messages per day”
He added that the mother of the ex-columnist should have taken a
“first name from the calendar”
and called her
“Corinne for example”
. During the hearing before the Court of Appeal on February 29, the Advocate General considered that, the first name being an
“essential attribute”
of identity,
“attacking Ms. Sy’s first name because of its origin supposed foreigner is a disrespect or even contempt for France
. Ms. Sy had detailed the consequences of these comments on her personal life.
“I receive 3 to 4,000 hate messages per day, excrement of messages, I am the subject of online harassment, I am targeted by death threats, calls for my rape and stoning,”
she declared. .
On Thursday, she praised to AFP a judgment which is
“a great victory which goes beyond (her)”
and the
“end of a long ordeal which cost me my career and my health”
.
“We welcome this conviction which reminds us that the law is clear on the subject and that there do not exist, contrary to what Mr. Zemmour would like, first names and second-class citizens
,” added his lawyer, Me Antoine Vey. Mr. Zemmour, for his part, indicated that he intended to appeal to the Court of Cassation. In a press release, he denounced
“these politicized judges (who) want to condemn (him) for intimidating the French”
.
“The political judges got Fillon, they won’t get me
,” he concluded.