It is not easy to narrate or visualize what happened between the renowned French writer Gabriel Matzneff and the then girl—now a writer and editor—Vanessa Springora since November 1985 and over three years. Matzneff, who was 50 years old when he decided to seduce a 14-year-old girl, with whom he had a relationship basically based on sex, already had extensive pedophile experience. Not only that: he had written it, it had been published and it was celebrated and awarded by broad French literary circles.
“Once you have held in your arms, kissed, caressed, possessed a 13-year-old boy, a 15-year-old girl, everything else seems dull, heavy, insipid,” Matzneff wrote in books like
Les moins de seize ans
(Those under 16 years old), published in 1974 and, be careful, republished in 2005. “July 28, 1986. 5:20 p.m. “My sex has triumphed over the hymen of my beautiful 14-year-old lover,” he declaimed in his
Diaries
Of Him. Springora, who took years to understand that this was not love but psychological and sexual abuse, manipulation and rape, responded with the book
Consent
, published in 2020. A literary, cultural, social, political and even legal phenomenon, which shocked to the country and caused changes in its legislation, and whose film adaptation is now being released in Spain, directed by Vanessa Filho and with Springora herself as co-writer.
In addition to a narrative, dialogues, a portrait of characters, a succession of situations and an interior and exterior path of its creatures, a look, a style is needed to compose a film like this. A way of applying cinematic meaning to what is pure abjection. However, Filho does not have it. It is about using cinematographic language in an honest but clean way; true but considered; evocative of that hell, but never explicit; Let it not be ambiguity that dominates in that view because in this case indeterminacy does not fit; that there is not a single crack so that those sequences, or certain shots, which can only be depraved, have a minimum breath of eroticism.
How long does each shot last, where the camera is placed, how the characters move, what degrees of nudity do the bodies of that 50-year-old man and that girl show... These are decisions to be made and, with all of them, that look is shaped. . And in the sex sequences contained
in Consent
, at least for the person writing this, there is neither style nor the necessary modesty. Of course, the interpreter of Springora, Kim Higelin, is of legal age: she is 24 years old. Another thing is her appearance.
On the other hand, in a second branch of the film, fundamental in the social aspect, Filho does make some formal and substantive decisions of notable merit. Firstly, with the portrait of Springora's mother, he chose to consider her daughter an adult who should make her own decisions. So, when he discovers their relationship, he seems to fly into a rage. “He is a pervert, a depraved person. A pedophile. But everyone knows it! However, a friend of the writer, with whom she interacts among the intellectuals of Paris, when the child threatens to leave school if she prevents her from “living her love,” she takes a terrible step aside, while threatening her with going to the police without then doing so: “Do what you want, but then don't complain.”
The drawing of that mother is brutal, as is that of literary circles, and there a paradigmatic sequence reveals in a documentary way (Filho's accurate decision) the complicity of a good part of society: a television program with the writer among his guests , in which the presenter defines it this way, to the laughter of most of his fellow members: “If there really is a sex educator, it is Gabriel Matzneff. He likes to seduce, but above all he likes to be the first.”
The consent
Direction
: Vanessa Filho.
Performers:
Kim Higelin, Jean-Paul Rouve, Laetitia Casta and Sara Giraudeau.
Genre
: drama. France, 2023.
Duration
: 119 minutes.
Premiere: April 19.
All the culture that goes with you awaits you here.
Subscribe
Babelia
The literary news analyzed by the best critics in our weekly newsletter
RECEIVE IT
_